A few years in the past a crowd-averse buddy taught me a precious lesson: Why wait hours to get right into a sizzling restaurant when you could possibly stroll proper right into a much less in style restaurant of roughly equal worth? That is how I got here to like Pizza Moto.
Pizza Moto, now a cell pizza caterer, seems unbelievable Neapolitan pies and was my alternative for Roberta’s. And ever since, I’ve believed that just about each high-end, impossible-to-get-into, give-up-your-first-born-for-a-reservation restaurant has a dupe. (For these unfamiliar with dupe-ology, it’s the research of equally high-quality substitutes for in style merchandise.)
In his latest story in The New Yorker, Adam Iscoe writes that “bots, mercenaries and desk scalpers have turned the restaurant reservation system inside out.” He particulars the acute lengths diners and scalpers are keen to go to get into Sailor, Roscioli, the Polo Bar, Tatiana, Carbone, Torrisi and others. It’s completely fantastic to maintain the dream of eating at Don Angie alive, however I’m right here to say that restaurant reservations usually are not like Beyoncé live shows. They aren’t coming to your metropolis for one evening solely. And fairly than purchase into the false shortage, purchase into the dupe life-style.
A Polo Bar Dupe
The one method a normie can get a reservation at the Polo Bar on East fifty fifth Road is by calling the restaurant at 10 a.m., which often means being placed on maintain for a not insignificant period of time. In case you safe one, you’ll stroll right into a warmly lit eating room full of leather-based cubicles and extra horse portraits than the Kentucky Derby Museum. The menu skews American chophouse classics. (A chophouse in New York Metropolis? Groundbreaking.) And don’t neglect to decorate neatly!
Or you could possibly go to South Road Seaport and dine at Carne Mare, Andrew Carmellini’s enticing surf-and-turf restaurant. It additionally has, conveniently, giant leather-based cubicles, fantastic service and Italian-leaning takes on chophouse classics. You will get a reservation nearly any time, and it comes with a stunning view of the East River and the Wavetree, the final iron-hulled, totally rigged three-masted iron crusing ship on this planet. Order the veal chop, the Wagyu filet, the home “wedgini” salad with pancetta dressing, and the layered chocolate cake for dessert.
Carne Mare 89 South Road, Pier 17 (F.D.R. Drive)
A Tatiana Dupe
The first purpose that this Lincoln Middle restaurant (and Pete Wells’s No. 1 restaurant within the metropolis) is unimaginable to get into is as a result of it’s so very small. Tatiana is constructed for pre-symphony eating, not for the form of Battle Royale-style reservations sport extra widespread in Decrease Manhattan.
Discovering a Tatiana dupe wasn’t straightforward, as a result of the restaurant’s menu is so distinctive, mixing components of Caribbean, Black American and African cooking in entertainingly scrumptious methods. However I’d say that the French-Senegalese restaurant Cafe Rue Dix in Crown Heights comes shut. It’s eclectic sufficient to have beignets, Senegalese spring rolls and Spanish-style grilled shrimp on the menu, however critical sufficient to serve a multicourse menu of Senegalese specialties like thiebou jen (stewed pink snapper with jollof rice) and thiebou yapp (braised lamb shank over damaged rice).
Cafe Rue Dix 1451 Bedford Avenue (Park Place)
A Carbone Dupe
At this level, saying that you simply ate at Carbone has turn into extra necessary than the meal itself. Nobody talks about what they ate at Carbone, simply that they had been in there and also you weren’t and isn’t that form of unhappy for you?
After all I would dine at Carbone at some point, however expertise has taught me that variations of what it’s promoting — modernized, high-end takes on pink sauce favorites — are broadly out there in New York Metropolis. Simply take a look at Frank (hen Parm, child!), Cafe Spaghetti, Bamonte’s, Cafe Fiorello and numerous others. And on the finish of the day if it’s the air of exclusivity that attracts you to a restaurant, are you actually a real restaurant lover in any respect?
Frank 88 Second Avenue (East Fifth Road)
Cafe Spaghetti 126 Union Road (Columbia Road)
Bamonte’s 32 Withers Road (Union Avenue)
Cafe Fiorello 1900 Broadway (West sixty fourth Road)
Learn previous editions of the publication right here.
In case you’re having fun with what you’re studying, please think about recommending it to others. They will enroll right here.
Have suggestions? Ship us a observe at wheretoeat@nytimes.com.
Observe NYT Meals on TikTok and NYT Cooking on Instagram, Fb, YouTube and Pinterest.
