Reality or delusion: Pasta ought to at all times be cooked al dente or agency to the tooth.
The supply of this delusion appears to be transcontinental confusion. The American approach of serving absolutely cooked pasta with sauce dolloped on high is completely different from the Italian approach of serving pasta and sauce mixed. In Italian recipes, the pasta is cooked twice: first in boiling water, after which once more with seasonings or sauce, so leaving it barely undercooked — al dente — within the first stage is sensible. You may at all times add extra sauce or cooking water to complete cooking the pasta, however you may’t return if it’s overcooked.
However the tenderness of your pasta is absolutely as much as you; even in Italy, there’s room for private desire. Some individuals like slightly resistance, and a few pasta shapes are good with slightly little bit of chew (good day, bucatini). Others need pasta to provide approach instantly. Do not forget that pasta will at all times cook dinner slightly extra after it’s drained, so cease earlier than it will get so gentle that it’s going to crumble by the point it will get to the desk. And it’s at all times a good suggestion to cook dinner pasta to al dente while you’re going to bake it in a casserole.
Verdict: False. Cook dinner to your desire.
❖
Reality or delusion: Pasta must cook dinner at a rolling boil all the time.
In 2009, Harold McGee, a cooking scientist and Instances columnist, enlisted the queens of Italian American cooking, Marcella Hazan and Lidia Bastianich, to check the custom of conserving pasta at a boil. Since then, many specialists have reproduced their outcomes: It doesn’t make a lot distinction whether or not the water is simmering or boiling. Dried pasta will cook dinner by way of at any temperature from 180 levels to 212 levels. (Contemporary pasta, particularly stuffed ones like wontons and tortellini, must be cooked solely at a simmer; the tumult of boiling can burst them open.)
What does make a distinction is stirring. On the decrease temperature, pasta must be stirred no less than each minute or so to distribute the sticky starch particles, which prevents clumping. As a result of a rolling boil strikes the pasta within the pot, it does the stirring for you.
In case you don’t thoughts paying fixed consideration to your pasta whereas it’s cooking, you may cook dinner it at a decrease temperature. However should you like so as to add it, stir it after which depart it alone till the timer goes off, preserve it on the boil.
Verdict: Fantasy.
❖
Reality or delusion: It is best to wait till the pasta water has reached a boil so as to add the salt.
This delusion appears to this point from a time when cooking pots have been product of tin, aluminum and different metals simply corroded or pitted by salt. The thought was that including salt to chilly water might trigger injury, as a result of the undissolved salt sits on the underside. However the quantity of salt in pasta water — 1 heaping tablespoon per gallon — isn’t almost sufficient to break as we speak’s pots and pans. That mentioned, it’s a good suggestion to not let the salty pasta water cool within the pot after the cooking; the earlier you dump it out and rinse the pot, the better it’s to scrub off the inevitable cloudy salt deposits.
Verdict: Fantasy. Add the salt any time you want.
❖
Reality or Fantasy: Salting pasta water makes the noodles cook dinner sooner.
It’s true that salt raises the boiling level of water, however not in a approach that issues for pasta functions. In case you added sufficient salt to truly pace up the cooking, your pasta can be inedible.
Verdict: Fantasy.
❖
Reality or delusion: Pasta cooking water ought to style as salty because the ocean.
In my earlier article, I cooked eight batches of spaghetti at various salt ranges, starting from none to Pacific Ocean to Mediterranean Sea (3 to 4 p.c, or about half a cup of salt per gallon.) It seems: Seawater is simply too salty.
As I labored my approach up from a teaspoon to a tablespoon of kosher salt per gallon, the pasta was noticeably undersalted, and its taste obtained misplaced within the completed dish. I most preferred water that tasted as salty as a lightweight rooster inventory, or two tablespoons per gallon of water. (Right here’s the piece in query, with an much more in-depth exploration.)
